Metal Vs Asphalt Roofing Comparison
Best and Worst Gutter Guards from Lowes, Home Depot, Menards /@Roofing Insights
|More DIY-friendly||Not DIY-friendly|
When comparing asphalt with metal, the durability of metal is its crowning glory. A roof that will probably outlast its owner is a good investment. Asphalt is more economical, and that’s why it has most of the residential market now. As metal becomes more economically viable, that may change.
Installing A Metal Roof Over Shingles
If you currently have an asphalt roof and need to replace it, you may have an option of installing a metal roof over shingles. This will enable you to save money on tear-off, which can be as much as $1,200-3,000. Its best to speak with your roofer about this, because it may not be recommended depending on your roof structure, ventilation, and other factors.
Metal Roofing Prices Per Sheet
Metal roof panels are a very popular roofing choice, especially if you are looking for a budget friendly material. Economical corrugated metal sheet panels cost $3 6.5 per square foot installed, or $300-650 per square of roofing.
Metal sheet panels are available in a number of different styles, including: R-panel, 5V-crimp, corrugated and through-fastened panels.
They are made of either galvanized or galvalume steel and vary in thickness from 24-30 gauge steel. These panels can be painted or left as bare metal.
Cheap metal panels are good option for a barn, a storage space or a cabin style home.
Home Depot has a very large selection of various types of metal panels, sold in sheets. Steel metal sheets are available in various lengths from 5, 8, 10, 12, 16 ft. Sheet prices range from $18 to 52 per metal sheet. The most popular are 12 ft Classic Rib Steel panels that cost $39.84 each.
Recommended Reading: Hydrostop Premium Coat System
Metal Roof Installation Cost Factors
Metal roof installation costs are about the same price or slightly more than your metal panels or shingles. For example, aluminum roof shingles cost about $4.60 per square foot and $10 per square foot installed, while galvanized steel roof panels cost $3.35 per square foot and $7.75 per square foot installed. Many factors will weigh in on the total cost to install your new roof.
Diy Metal Roof Cost Vs Hiring A Local Roofer
A DIY metal roof will cost $2,000 to $5,000 versus the average $5,000 to $12,000 to have one installed professionally. Some are easier to install than others, but most are more difficult to work with than materials like asphalt shingles.
Improper application could result in a less efficient structure, leaking problems and a shorter lifespan. When you work with a professional, they can guarantee the best results and are likely to get better rates on materials than you would independently. Check out these truths about DIY roofing for more information.
Still have questions? Call a Metal Roofer for more details.
Read Also: Add Overhang To Side Of House
Got It We’ll Get You Connected With A Local Pro Asap
Thank you for allowing QualitySmith to assist you. Come back and see us again soon!
If you choose Home Depot to repair your roof, a professional will conduct a pre-inspection, give you regular updates on the project and conduct a final inspection. The cost of installation already includes the fee of delivering all of your roofing materials and the charge of removing the old materials once the project is complete. If you have a Home Depot credit card, you may be able to take advantage of special discounts or credit offers, such as no interest for 12 months if you spend a certain amount of money.
How A Metal Roof Helps You Save Money
Despite higher upfront cost, the advantages of having a metal roof over your house far outweigh the extra expense. What people often neglect to include in the price are costs of dealing with roof leaks, ice dams and other repairs that begin to occur at around 5 years after installing an asphalt roof.
For example, a simple roof repair will cost you at least $300-500. Dealing with ice dams starts at about $500-1500, depending on the extent of damage. These estimates also do not include the cost of interior repairs, which can range from $300-2,000 each time you have a big leak!
So for the majority of homeowners, within the first 7-10 years, the compounded cost of an asphalt roof will be almost as much as a metal roof.
On top of this, consider the fact that asphalt shingles only last about 14-18 years , where as a quality metal roof lasts at least 50 years.
So in that time span, you will need to spend money on re-roofing with asphalt shingles at least 3 times! Obviously, in the long run, living with an asphalt roof is significantly more expensive.
Finally, keep in mind that you will be spending 20-35% more on air conditioning costs with an asphalt roof, because metal simply reflects up to 90% of solar heat, making your AC run a lot less.
Recommended Reading: How To Add A Gable Overhang
Resale Value Of A Metal Roof
One of the greatest long term advantages of a metal roof is that it boasts a very high return on investment. Across the US, you can get at least 90% ROI when you resell a house with a metal roof. However, in areas with snow and ice dams, as well as fires and high winds, the ROI of a metal roof can be as high as 95-97%
Compared to asphalt shingles, a metal roof can boost your home value by as much as 5-6%. Most homeowners dont like to deal with roofing problems, and are more willing to buy home where their roof will last for decades to come without any leaks.
Prices By Metal Gauge
Don’t Buy Materials at Lowe’s and Home Depot
The rate of metal by gauge ranges from $1.75 to $7.00 per square foot.
The gauge is a measurement of how thick it is. The smaller the number, the thicker the panel or shingle. For example, 24-gauge is thicker than 29-gauge.
Thicker products cost more than thinner ones. When looking at these materials from a perspective of their thickness, manufacturers calculate them by square foot and, though the price difference is small in increments, it can add up quickly.
Average Metal Roof Price by Gauge
|$5.00 – $7.00||High wind areas|
*Some products are only available in specific gauges. For example, modular press-formed granular coated products only come in 26-gauge.
*Some products are only available in specific gauges. For example, modular press-formed granular coated products only come in 26-gauge.
Also Check: Skylight Installation Metal Roof
Lowes Metal Roof Price Variations Based On Location
Honestly, I do not know how the company comes up with pricing in different locations, but Im sure it has to do with demand and cost of delivery. The cheapest price I have found is in Glenville, NY . It is $32.90 per 3×12 panel.
Highest prices are in stores where these panels are NOT in stock. In Montgomery, AL, our benchmark panels cost $40.38. In Columbus, OH, and Helena, MT the same $40.38.
Basically you are paying about 13% premium for delivery to the store.
Metal Roofing Cost Vs Premium Materials
Since metal is considered a high-end material, it makes sense to compare its cost to other premium roofs, such as cedar shingles, slate, synthetic slate, clay and concrete tile.
|$7 14||20 40 years|
Looking at the price difference vs benefits derived from high-end roofs, it is clear that a metal roof offers the best value.
Don’t Miss: Rv Roof Repair Cost
Metal Roofing Cost Guide
Homewyse Cost Guides estimate approximate cost ranges for basic work in typical conditions. The estimates should only be used for preliminary planning. Homewyse estimates are NOT substitutes for quotes from qualified vendors. Homewyse strongly recommends that you contact reputable professionals for an accurate assessment of work required and costs for your project – before making any decisions or commitments.
Metal Roof Shingles And Tiles
Metal shingle- or tile roofing looks quite different than sheet roofing. With these, metal is formed into shapes that imitate Spanish and mission tile, wood shakes, slate, and Victorian metal tiles. Most are made from painted or coated steel or aluminum that has been pressed or formed into realistic shapes.
In addition, metal shingles are typically given multiple-layer factory finishes that complete the realistic effect of mimicking other materials.
In fact, some metal shingle roofing materials are amazingly convincing at imitating the look of other materials. Producers of painted metal products reduce tell-tale sheen by texturing the metal, layering the finish, and applying granulated-stone topcoats.
These products, typically tile or slate lookalikes, can be hard to distinguish from the real thing.
Metal shingle systems are manufactured as panels that have the appearance of several tiles or shingles joined together. They also come as individual shingles. The larger panels, typically about 4 feet long, are designed for quick installation and to bridge across irregularities. Single shingles, meant to be applied one by one, can be easier to handle and more accommodating on irregular or complicated roofs.
Most paneled shingles can be installed over one or two layers of existing roofing. The individual shingles require tearing-off the old roof so the shingles can be applied to a firm, flat roof deck.
Read Also: Rv Rubber Roof Repair Kit
Planning Your Metal Roofing Project
As you begin planning your roofing project, consider the following three tips to help make it a successful project:
- Determine what is going to be done with your old roofin some cases, you will not have to pay for the removal of the old roof, since it may be possible to install the metal roof on top of what is there.
- Check with your municipality/HOA before you buyas with any modification to the exterior of your home, you might violate local HOA statutes by installing a metal roof.
- Ask the roofing companies you have requested bids from how long their proposal is good for. Any number of factors in the metals market could cause the price to go up if you sit on the bid too long before giving the go-ahead.
Residential Metal Roof Cost Estimator
All of these cost factors can be helpful in determining the end-price of your project. With the square footage of your home and pitch, you can figure how many squares of materials you’ll need and what the project total might be with labor and overhead.
Metal Roof Cost Per House Square Foot
|Square Footage of Home|
Don’t Miss: Cost To Install Trusses
Does Home Depot Do Roofing Jobs
Home DepotHomecontractorsHome Depotdo roofing
. Thereof, do Home Depot do roofing?
Home Depot will continue to sell roofing, gutter, insulation, and siding products. According to the Home Depot website, the company partners with installers and home service professionals who meet the highest standards for experience, know-how and customer service.
Similarly, does Home Depot do metal roofing? Metal Roofing – Roof Panels – The Home Depot.
Just so, does Lowe’s do roofing?
Roofing Install. Protect your home with a new roof. Let Lowe’s professionals install it by calling 1-800-GO-LOWES.
What is the best shingles on the market for roofing?
Asphalt Shingle Roofing: 4 of the Best Brands in the U.S.
- GAF Marquis WeatherMax® The GAF Marquis WeatherMax shingles are one of the best reasons that three-tab shingles have remained the most popular roofing material in the country.
- CertainTeed XT 25.
How Much Does An Interlock Roof Cost
Installing Home Depot Gutters
Our product is not an off-the-shelf roofing material. Plus the installation procedures vary from structure to structure. For instance, a home with a 3/12 pitch is easier for our installers to work on therefore labour costs will be less expensive. A home with no valleys, chimneys, skylights, or dormers will also be less expensive. Please contact Rachelle for pricing info.
Don’t Miss: Can You Put Skylights In A Metal Roof
Galvanized Steel Shingles Roof Cost
Galvanized Steel Shingles cost $3 to $3.50 per square foot and start at $7.50 per square foot installed for interlocking steel shingles. The two common types of galvanized steel used in roofing are G-60, which is a low-end product used for roofing on garden sheds or workshops, and G-90, which is used for residential roofing applications. During the manufacturing stage, the metal is treated with a thin coat of zinc oxide and painted with a resin-based architectural coating called Kynar 500 to preserve the finish.
Who Should Invest In Metal Roofing
If you plan to move within 5-7 years you dont need to drop extra $7-10K on a metal roof. A newly installed asphalt roof will help you sell your home at a good price, because homeowners love the idea of having a new roof.
Keep in mind that your location may also be a factor. If you live in areas that get a lot of extreme weather, prospective buyers may really appreciate the fact that your house has a metal roof. While it may not necessarily boost your house value, it will help you sell your house faster and for a price you want.
However, If you want to spend a long time in your home, or even retire in it then metal is definitely the better option. Particularly for elderly individuals, metal roofing may be a necessary long term investment.
With age, it becomes exceedingly difficult to deal with roofing problems and to navigate working with roofing contractors, so they good work, instead of just taking your money. Unfortunately, there are too many horror stories of unscrupulous roofers taking advantage of seniors, and especially women.
Being a virtually maintenance free product , a metal roof will last at least 30-40 years without any leaks. After decades, original paint MIGHT begin to fade. However 90% of all architectural metal roofs have a 50 year paint warranty, and the chance that you will ever need to use it is less than 0.01%
As you can see the roof is in great shape no issues with paint and no leaks!
Don’t Miss: Corrugated Roofing Overhang
Metal Roof Cost Vs Asphalt Shingles
For many homeowners looking to replace an old roof, the choice often boils down to metal vs. asphalt shingles. In the short run, traditional shingles are a very budget-friendly option, with prices starting as low as $3 per square foot installed. These are 3-tab shingles, that look flat and last only about 10-12 years, sometimes even less.
More expensive, designer architectural shingles, last up to 15 years, and look significantly better. They run $5-7 per square foot on average, but can cost as much as $7-8 per square foot installed. Thus you would be looking at spending anywhere from $4,500 to 10,500 for a new asphalt shingles roof on a 1,500 sq.ft. ranch style home.
To compare, the average cost for a metal roof is about 40-50% more than basic shingles. However, this roof will last at least twice as long, and will require minimal maintenance. Upon closer examination, the math is actually in favor of installing a metal roof. This is because you can get a low-end metal shingle, which is still superior in longevity and performance to the most expensive asphalt product, for about $6.5-7 per square foot installed.
Thus, you can install a new metal roof for about $9,750-10,500 on the same 1,500 sq.ft. ranch style home. This roof will protect your home in any weather, especially against ice dams, snow, rain, hail and fire. Many homeowners spend this much on an architectural asphalt roof, but dont get any of the benefits of metal.
Exposed Vs Hidden Fastener Metal Roofing
Exposed fastener roofing costs $250 to $700 per square after installation versus hidden fastener styles at $600 to $1,400 per square after installation. The fastener type affects price and efficiency.
Exposed fasteners are more economical than hidden. However, the fastener â which typically consists of a roofing screw and washer head â is exposed to the elements which increases the risk for leaking. A good installer will remove the existing material and use a “peel and stick” underlayment to minimize this risk. The standard gauges for this style are 26 and 29.
Concealed fasteners are more expensive than exposed, but they are hidden from the elements, giving greater protection from exposure and potential leaking. They also create a sleeker appearance. The standard gauges for this style are 24 and 26.
You May Like: Skylight For Metal Roof
Steel Shingle And Shake:
In Canada there is a wide range of steel roofing products designed for residential use. G90 is the accepted standard for roofing. G110 and G115 will perform better against acid rain or in marine environments. A high-end steel system will not need battens and strapping for installation, and panels will be interlocking . A galvanized steel roof with interlocking design and PVDF finish will have a better life expectancy than cheaper steel options. Coatings on a high-end steel system sometimes include reflective pigments to enhance energy efficiency. Keeping in mind that there is no steel roofing product that unconditionally guarantees against rust, cosmetic life is shorter than functional life.
Maintenance Required: Optional, re-paint to cover rust.Re-Roofing Cycles Over 50 Year Period: 1 if corroded through back of panel.Expect to Pay: $10.00 $13.00 CAD per square foot installed.
Example of a Shake Style Aluminum Roofing System. Other aluminum variations include shingle, slate and tile styles.
Metal Roof Vs Shingles Cost
Today, asphalt roof shingles are installed on over 90% of all US homes. However, a smart homeowner, who wants the best protection for the home, should consider metal roofing.
Roof replacement cost is about $4,500 for asphalt shingles, and $7,500 for metal shingles, installed on a 1,500 sq.ft. ranch style home.
In this roofing guide, we will take a close look at the real long term costs of metal vs asphalt roofs, the pros and cons of each of these materials, as well as longevity, durability and energy efficiency of metal roofs compared to asphalt shingles.
Get started on your re-roofing project, by contacting local roofing pros to get free quotes for a new roof install.
You May Like: Shed Eave Overhang